PDA

View Full Version : NSW Harbour Bridge Crash


Knight
30-03-2007, 06:30 AM
Harbour warned of 'phantom' vessel
Friday Mar 30 05:00 AEST
By ninemsn staff

Ahead of Wednesday night's tragic boat collision, skippers in Sydney Harbour were warned that a private vessel was travelling without its lights on — and were advised to proceed with caution.

But a radio blackspot in the area may have prevented the HarbourCat Pam Burridge from hearing the crucial warning that could have saved four lives.

Police scaled back their search last night for 14-year-old ice skater Morgan Innes, who is now believed to have been killed when the private vessel she was a passenger on collided with the HarbourCat underneath Sydney Harbour Bridge at about 11pm AEST on Wednesday.

Three people, including NSW Ice Skating Association (NSW ISA) president Alan Blinn, 47, and Simone Moore, 44, who is also involved with the NSW ISA, have been confirmed dead with eight others injured.

More than 24 hours after the accident, details have emerged of an emergency call sent out by the ferry master which could have prevented the tragedy.

Authorities had spotted the 10m private craft, believed to be the Merinda, operating without running lights near the Harbour Bridge's southern pylon at about 10.30pm.

It is believed the skipper of the HarbourCat was unable to hear the warning, or subsequent chatter as other skippers discussed the "phantom" craft on open-air maritime radio, due to a communications breakdown.

Union sources told The Daily Telegraph the alert may have not been heard by the HarbourCat due to a radio blackspot.

Two Sydney Ferries employees were returning the out of service Pam Burridge back to its dock, when they struck the wooden vessel underneath the bridge, causing it to capsize and nearly split in half.

All 12 passengers of the private craft were spilled into the water, with passenger Olympian Liz Cain having part of her leg amputated upon impact.

A family friend, lawyer John Foley, said Cain passed out when she saw her injured leg and would have drowned had it not been for her quick-acting son who was also flung from the vessel, Australian ice skating champion Sean Carlow.

"Sean spotted her and grabbed her and rescued her," Foley said.

Sydney Ferries chief executive officer Rear Admiral Geoff Smith said the company is investigating the cause of the accident.

"We need to find out how it happened, why it happened and take whatever action is necessary to prevent it in the future," Smith said.

Hampering the investigation, however, is the fact that the HarbourCat was not fitted with black-box style technology — despite promises from Sydney Ferries two years ago to fit all of their vessels with the device.

The skipper of the HarbourCat tested negative for blood-alcohol content, and has been cleared of any responsibility for the crash.


Hi all,
Well, in addition to cycling, I'm also a figure skater and I personally knew all onboard that private vessel. I cannot give more information than what is already in the article, so please don't ask for it. I guess the article above was the first part of finding any sort of closure. The skating community has been hit extremely hard by this tragic accident. The fact that it was mostly accidental and probably preventable makes it too cruel to occur to these people, to any people.

Liz Cain, the woman whose leg was amputated is my coach. Her whole family was onboard. Morgan, the missing girl, is a close friend.

I will be visiting the hospital that Liz is currently in during this week. I guess I was going to ask what you would say in this situation. But do you say anything? If yes, then what? What words could bring comfort to my friends and colleagues? And what can be said to the ferry pilot to comfort him?

Thank you in advance for your support.

arpit
30-03-2007, 06:42 AM
Give em all a big hug! It works much better than just saying 'there there'; or equivalent.



I;m not sure whether the injured people will get much sympathy on farkin.

It strikes me from what I;ve read that people who rode their bikes the wrong way down a busy road at night without lights and subsequently were injured by an oncoming bus would be ridiculed rather than pitied on this forum - particularly if there was a video of the occurrence! This seems to be, based on what you posted, a scenario roughly analogous to the ferry incident. (No nav lights, not giving way to a ferry, busy harbour etc.)

That said, any preventable death is unfortunate. Sorry it happened to people you knew.

BrumbyJack
30-03-2007, 06:58 AM
Hi Knight,

Were you on the cruise??? What a terrifying ordeal for all concerned :(

Just tell those you love and care about how you feel, don't hold back on the tears or the words. Don't pussyfoot around, it's not like you can pretend a leg isn't missing.

Don't dwell on the negatives. Look for some positives. Just be there... love and support is really what is needed.

Coaching skills aren't really diminished by an injury like that, so lets hope your coach can recover successfully and get back into doing what she obviously loves. Getting back to health and recovering her independance will be a tougher, but still not insurmountable, task.

Where there is a will, there is a way. Just ask Michael Milton (that said with no disprespect meant for the injured).

Knight
30-03-2007, 03:10 PM
Thank you arpit and BrumbyJack for your replies, greatly appreciated.

To BrumbyJack, no I wasn't on the boat.

Since this morning, more information has been released.

http://news.ninemsn.com.au/article.aspx?id=257650
"Witness saw yellow light on smashed boat"

Mahoney_007
30-03-2007, 04:41 PM
Sorry about your loss mate, I was a bit teary watching it on the news last night actually.


Although I do agree with what Arpit has said, it is a massive waste of life that possibly could of been prevented, without knowing all the facts I probably shouldnt be diving in here ........But in that last report the witness said she saw " a yellowish light, like one you would use in a house, a 100-watt bulb." now that sounds awfully like the cabin light to me?

I'm no expert but I know you are supposed to have a port side (red) light a starboard side (green) and a stern light (white) none of which are yellow, or anywhere near looking like a 100 watt bulb and you are supposed to be able to see nav lights for a couple of miles.

That may sound like I am being a prick, sorry if it does, I do not mean to come across as someone saying "They Deserved it" by no means, but it could be a reason why the ferry simply didnt see the boat.

Not sure how many of you have been on the water in a boat at night but its fucking diffucult to see anything thats not lit up and I would suspect these guys were on the final run home so were probably a bit tried and possibly running a bit quicker than normal and were not looking for a light bulb inside a cabin.


In any case its a massive tradgedy, sorry to all those involved or concerned if I have offended.

Knight
30-03-2007, 06:00 PM
Mahoney_007, thank you for your reply, it is greatly appreciated.

I completely understand your comment and take no offence whatsoever. Thank you for your sentiments at this time. Yes, vessels must have a port and starboard light. Yes, the yellow light was not a navigational light and would have most likely been the cabin light. Please understand that I am only relating information that I know first hand and do not mean to accuse, defend or give further information. I have seen the boat and been on it once before and I know that the lights are kept on at all times and that its pilot is extremely cautious and experienced.

Matthew

Knight
03-04-2007, 02:21 PM
Ok, well Morgan's body has been found.

So now its the long road to recovery for my coach and then the trials and tribulations of the investigation to come. My coach still doesn't know about the deaths..we're not sure what to tell her once she comes out of a medically induced coma.

Thanks to those who replied for their sympathy and advice.
Matt

Knight
29-04-2007, 06:29 PM
Its now a month after the crash and things are slowly getting back to what is almost normal.

Once again, thank you to those who replied earlier. It was extremely awkward waiting outside the ward with the other skaters. Only 2 visitors at a time were allowed. Most of us had no idea what we would say when we went in and there was a very nervous silence.

Not much more information has arisen about what actually happened that night but there have been some developments. My coach has since returned home. They are renovating their house to accomodate for her disability. As far as any of us can tell, she is back to her old self and is extremely enthusiastic about returning to the ice rink.

Lastly, there has been a foundation set up to "aid young ice skaters in the pursuit of their ice skating dreams and providing opportunities for disadvantaged youth to experience the “fun” that brings all skaters to the ice each day." Over the last week, members of the skating community have been collecting donations from around the Circular Quay area. Any contribution, however small, is greatly appreciated. If I am assisting in the near future, I will post up some identifying information. Please come and say hi and let me know who you are if you are passing by.

Morgan Innes Foundation URL: http://www.morganinnes.com/

Thank you for reading and keep safe.